Ciudad de México’s Italian scene thrives on contrasts: traditional trattoria vibes in colonial neighborhoods, avant-garde pizza in high-rise zones, and hidden gems serving $100 steak frites. My #1 pick? 50 Friends in Polanco. It’s not just the 4.7 rating (1,859 reviews) or the 98.2 score — it’s the way they blend Mexican ingredients into Italian classics.
1. 50 Friends
Address: Av. Emilio Castelar 95, Polanco Signature dish: Chocolate pizza ($450) Price range: $$
Polanco’s 50 Friends wins for audacity. They serve "cymbals" (cannelloni with quail and truffle) and "wealth" (a play on bollito misto with arrachera and chorizo). The 4.7 rating feels earned — one reviewer raves, "The chocolate pizza is genius and slightly terrifying." Open until 1am Friday/Saturday, it’s ideal for late-night carbs.
2. Lucca Pedregal
Address: Av. de Las Fuentes 556, Jardines del Pedregal Signature dish: Prosciutto pizza ($380) Price range: None listed
Step into Lucca Pedregal’s wine cellar and you’ll understand its 4.4 rating. Their "caprese pasta" uses heirloom tomatoes from Oaxaca and buffalo mozzarella flown in weekly. The terrace has views of the Pedregal golf course — perfect for sipping Chianti at sunset. One review notes, "The octopus carpaccio is so tender it melts like a dream." Open until midnight, it’s a weekend favorite.
3. La Posta Pacífico
Address: Av Pacífico 292, Coyoacán Signature dish: Carbonara pasta ($280) Price range: $$
Coyoacán’s La Posta Pacífico is the sleeper hit at #3. With 5,933 reviews, their "four cheese pizza" stays on the menu for a reason. The 4.6 rating comes from locals who return for the "trout with dill" and "pear salad." At $$ per person, it’s the most budget-friendly top-three pick. The 1–11pm hours let you start with aperitivo and end with tiramisu.
4. Argentalia
Address: Fray Pedro de Gante 11, Centro Histórico Signature dish: Clericot ($320) Price range: $$
Centro’s Argentalia (4.1 rating) leans into Italian-Mexican fusion. Try their "chorizo chimichurri" or "arrachera carpaccio." The 3,772 reviews highlight "grilled meat platters" as a standout. Open 9am–10:15pm daily, it’s great for lunch — just avoid the "raffle" unless you want to spend extra.
5. Nonsolo
Address: Calle Julio Verne 89, Polanco Signature dish: Camarones al ajillo ($390) Price range: $$
Polanco’s Nonsolo (4.5 rating) delivers refined simplicity. Their "promotion" deals on Tuesdays ($250 for pasta + wine) outshine pricier rivals. The 4.5 rating hinges on "accessible" service — staff speak fluent English and Spanish. Open until midnight Saturday, it’s the easiest Polanco option for non-residents.
If you only visit one, make it 50 Friends. Its fusion of Italian technique and Mexican ingredients isn’t just novel — it’s the future of CDMX dining.
